My Love for Black and White Photography
December 17, 2011 Leave a Comment
I believe I mentioned that I’m going to pursue black and white photography with a vengeance next year. I think lots of photographers overlook this style/genre of photography because, well, it’s the 21st century and there’s color photography now! Yes, I know…but that doesn’t mean we should leave the black and white images on the cutting room floor.
The thing is, in many respects, black and white photography is much harder than color because you have to look at your subjects so differently. When you’re photographing exactly what you see you can get instant feedback from your digital viewfinder to know if you like what you photographed or not but, if you are going to be doing the conversions in post-processing, you really don’t know what you have until you make the conversion…that is, until you have learned to “think” in terms of black and white images.
For instance, on the color wheel, certain colors are opposites and, therefore, look really great together on an image but, if those two opposite colors are almost exactly the same tonal range then they are going to make for one really sloppy looking black and white image. You need tonal range in order to make most black and white images have some pop – something that will grab the viewer’s eye and keep them engaged. So, instead of looking for colors that compliment each other you have to start viewing tonal range instead – and not everyone is good at that; it takes practice!
One way to get better at it is to look at every image you process and ask yourself, “Would I like this in black and white?” and then click that black and white adjustment layer in Photoshop and see if you were right at guessing if it would make for a good black and white image. The more you do this the more you’ll be able to start “seeing” the tonal range beneath the color and that will translate into knowing in the field or at your computer if what you’ve photographed will be stronger in color or in black and white.
Another difference in photographing for black and white is that it lends itself really well to hard lines and geometric shapes. Buildings, signs, automobiles – even people – will lend itself well to black and white photography if you look at it for tonal range as well.
Another plus for black and white photos is that they can be captured in almost any kind of lighting situation including full on midday sun. Whereas with a color image we are constantly trying to keep the whites from overexposing and the shadows from underexposing all at the same time, that’s not always the case with black and white images. In fact, if you really blow an exposure, save it and process it as a black and white image sometime and see what you think. That harsher contrast can often make for a very powerful black and white image – but the same image in color would end up in the recycle bin.
Today I spent the morning walking around Kansas City’s largest and oldest shopping area – the Country Club Plaza – looking for opportunities to create some black and white images. Even as the day went on and the sun was almost straight up in the sky I was still able to produce images that will make for some very interesting black and white photos. I saw this woman walking by the parking garage and waited for her to get right at the edge of the frame before I clicked the shutter, wanting her black frame to be offset by the white edges of the garage. I’m posting both the color version and the black and white so you can see how much stronger the black and white image is in this case. The color version is fine…technically, it works…but in my opinion, the black and white image really grabs the viewer and draws them in to all those sloping shapes and hard angles. Which, now, do you prefer?
The color version:
Or the black and white version?

